The directorial debut of Dave Patel is pouring its heart and soul into the film’s energy. The work, even though ultimately a finely-crafted and dynamic film, still fails at the same time precisely because of the insanely high energy it provides. From the sights and sounds to even the dense music soundtrack and the nearly-tangible smells of modern India, Monkey Man keeps relentlessly pushing and pushing.
But it feels like Patel, who is starring in the film at the same time, tried hard to bring across a more poignant and deeper message about the state of the biggest democracy in the world. The story of a downtrodden boy who grows up into a man thirsting for vengeance is easy to understand, though hard to empathise with. The reason for this is that in the film, somehow, everyone seems to be suffering. That plight turns into a series of individual spaces from which no one can escape.
This applies to the ritual character of Kid, but also to the beautiful women trapped in the glorified brothels of the upper floors of glamorous hotels. It applies to the corrupt cops on the street and to their commanders as well, whose hands are forever bloodied by the deeds they had or wanted to commit. Still, throughout all of this, castes are never mentioned, which is an odd blind spot for a film with these topics and societal context.
Chances are that for the film’s investors, it’s much more appealing to see a scenario where everyone is sort of bad in their own way instead of fully focusing on the powers that be. The main antagonist of the film could have played that role. But the script seemingly pulled away from pushing into the societal space where money is pouring in and very little pouring out, just like it has been for millennia.
Monkey Man is a stand-out action thriller that does both thrills and action really well. Yet, it is no White Tiger when it comes to its ability to address the current state of India’s wealth disparities. It does, sadly, just as little in showcasing what the future course of this unique but troubled nation could be.
